Electric vehicles and ecology. Pros and cons compared to ICE. Not everything is so clean

According to Avtostat, from January to May 2022, 1,119 unused electric vehicles were sold in Russia. This is 65% more than in the same period a year earlier. The dynamics of interest in electric vehicles in domestic realities is quite positive. On the one hand, they are perceived as gadgets on wheels with a mass of new chips that cannot be implemented on the basis of internal combustion engines (ICE). On the other hand, motorists are obviously concerned about environmental issues. Yes, electric cars do not irritate others with their exhaust gases. However, it is also impossible to call them 100% safe for the environment, in comparison with fossil fuel counterparts. This will be discussed.

⊕ Environmental benefits of electric cars

As practice shows, many people naively believe that electric cars are the future of mankind precisely from the point of view of a reverent attitude towards the ecology of the environment. However, it is important to understand that they certainly differ in certain advantages in this direction.

1. Electric motors keep the air fresh

An important environmental difference between electric vehicles is the virtual absence of an exhaust system, without which an internal combustion engine cannot exist. There is neither the roar of the engine coming from the muffler, nor this element in itself in the lower part of the stern of the body. As more electric cars replace traditional fossil-fuel vehicles, the air in cities becomes cleaner. According to statistics from the UK Transport Department in 2019, about 27% of harmful emissions into the air in the country were generated by gasoline and diesel vehicles. Apparently, in other states the situation is no less positive, so the transition to electric vehicles seems to be a way out of the situation.

Tesla Model S Plaid is not only eco-friendly, but also insanely powerful – incompatible qualities for cars based on internal combustion engines

2. CO₂ emissions are steadily decreasing

CO₂ or carbon dioxide is an insidious chemical compound that has been systematically accumulating in our planet’s atmosphere since the beginning of the industrial age. At the first stages of the planet’s existence, this substance was the dominant encircling the planet. However, as the process of photosynthesis progressed, its share gradually decreased from several tens to 0.04%. Universal motorization coupled with deforestation has reversed this process for several years in a row. Despite all the accompanying nuances, CO₂ emissions from electric motors are still lower. But zero, which will be discussed further in the text, they do not equal.

CO₂ emissions are decreasing as the concentration of electric cars increases, and this is a positive fact

3. The main emissions are taken out of the cities

When it comes to the environmental friendliness of electric cars, their opponents immediately begin to brandish arguments of far from always the most green energy generation for their “refueling”, as well as the production and disposal of batteries with a lot of all sorts of emissions. Such an opinion has the right to life, but it is still important to note that all these moments are usually carried out outside the big cities. This reduces the average percentage of harmful effects on each individual inhabitant of the planet, which positively affects the health of our entire species – the US Department of Energy confirms this.

Electric cars are used and charged in cities, but produced and supplied with electricity outside of them.

4. Less solid pad contamination

It is for the sake of environmental friendliness that some electric cars use drum brakes. This, for example, concerns the potentially mass model Volkswagen ID.3. Unlike an open disk system, this system is assembled in a limited space, which effectively collects waste from its life. As a result, particles of worn brake pads, which do not contain anything good for the environment, do not remain on city streets, as well as on highways. However, in this case, the first place still becomes the efficiency of stopping the vehicle, which helps save lives. When choosing an electric car, this must be taken into account initially.

Almost all Volkswagen ID.3 trim levels use drum brakes, which are more environmentally friendly than disc brakes.

5. Finishing materials are recycled

The green trend is forcing electric car manufacturers to reconsider the materials that are used in the interior of the body, among other things. This applies to seats, door cards and dashboard – they are trying to make everything as environmentally friendly as possible, made from recycled materials or raw materials suitable for further processing. The same BMW emphasizes that about 95% of the components of the i3 model can be reused. At the same time, the electric car is manufactured with minimal use of raw materials obtained from renewable rather than fossil sources.

⊖ Environmental disadvantages of electric cars

Despite a number of positive environmental aspects, there are many negative nuances in the production and operation of electric cars. Most of them don’t even think about it. It will be all the more important to dwell on the most important nuances in a little more detail.

1. Battery production is not environmentally friendly

On the one hand, emissions associated with the entire life of an electric vehicle are typically lower than those of an average static ICE vehicle, even when electricity production and generation are taken into account. On the other hand, one should not forget the generally recognized fact: the manufacture of any modern batteries is far from being the most environmentally friendly process. According to researchers from the Argonne National Laboratory, the production of a vehicle based on an electric motor is much worse for the environment than a similar model of a traditional plan. However, taking into account the operation, as already mentioned above, the situation is the opposite.

The huge batteries of electric cars usually consist of a large number of separate sections, which local craftsmen have even learned to change on their own.

2. Battery recycling is bad for the environment

First, the production of batteries itself harms the environment. Secondly, their further processing is also not 100% environmentally friendly. Moreover, it is important to clearly understand that rechargeable batteries systematically lose their effectiveness due to chemical aging processes. When it crosses the line of 70–80% of the full capacity, the battery has to be changed: the vehicle noticeably loses both in range and in dynamics. However, after active operation inside an electric vehicle, batteries, even with tangible degradation, can still be used in other areas. This will reduce the environmental burden.

Tesla batteries are, of course, recyclable, but this process is also not always environmentally friendly.

3. Not always green electricity is used

When electric vehicles are called transportation that does not use fossil fuels, this is only partly true. Don’t forget how electricity is generated. On the one hand, of course, there are wind and solar power plants that do not deplete the planet and do not emit harmful emissions into the atmosphere. On the other hand, these are far from being used everywhere – more often they burn all kinds of “fuel oil” and indulge in the division of a peaceful atom. To call all this something eco-friendly, even the language does not turn. However, even taking into account such a clarification, electric vehicles remain more environmentally friendly than “monsters” with internal combustion engines.

It is important not to forget how electricity is generated | L&T

4. There is increased tire wear

Another important environmental problem that many people simply forget about is the systematic erasure of tires. It is important to understand that due to the use of recovery technologies, electric vehicles treat wheels much worse than fossil fuel vehicles. As you move on the road surface of completely different quality, the rubber is systematically erased, forming dust. It is carried by air and even constantly resides in it. There is nothing good in it for the human respiratory organs – and for the surrounding ecology, for that matter.

Whether you like it or not, it is necessary to change tires on electric cars more often – at least, all other things being equal | Motor Biscuit

5. Mining of rare earth materials is on the rise

In the end, it is important to understand that different power plants are installed in electric vehicles. For the production of the most progressive, rare earth materials are used, the distribution of which is extremely limited. Moreover, their extraction is associated with an environmental burden, the responsibility for increasing which falls on the manufacturers of electric cars. However, not all manufacturers are trying to maximize the efficiency and reliability of the electric motors used, so the scale of the problem is considered to be not so serious. But it has a place to be – it’s a fact.

  • To the point: Electric motors are different. What are put in electric cars

Source: Trash Box

You may also like