Varese, raped for years. But for the tax judges it is not “a fact of extreme gravity”

For years she was raped and suffered physical, sexual and psychological abuse by her partner. Yet his story it is not considered by the tax courts as a «case of extreme gravityabsolutely out of any possible prediction, exceptional and inevitable ».

It happened in the province of Varese: the woman, who is now 36 years old, was used as a sexual slave and raped by comrade, psychiatric patient, even while she was pregnant, and if she did not submit to her will she was thrown out of the house. After the woman’s denunciation, the Busto Arsizio court issued a precautionary measure for the man, followed by an order from the mayor for compulsory medical treatment. A procedure has also been activated for the sole custody of the child. The woman’s partner, who ended up in a psychiatric facility, committed suicide in 2017.

The woman, left alone with her little son, decided to sell the house he had bought with him with tax breaks for his first home. But the five years from the purchase had not yet passed: the law provides, in this case, the restitution of tax benefits, except in the case of “serious and unforeseeable events”. So, when the Revenue Agency asked her to reimburse the benefits, the woman appealed.

The tax commission, however, with an order issued in recent days, he established that there was no “an event of extreme gravity, absolutely out of any possible prediction, exceptional and inevitable “, necessary for the request for restitution of tax benefits for the first home to be suspended. The third section of the Varese Provincial Tax Commission wrote: “The situation of severe inconvenience referred to by the applicant and, according to her, impeding the purchase of new property cannot be taken into consideration, from a regulatory point of view, as there is no objective and unpredictable impediment that cannot be avoided and such as to constitute an obstacle to the fulfillment of the obligation“. Therefore, in addition to the € 750 legal fees, the woman will be required to pay another € 4,000 (ie € 3,000 of deed tax plus the fine of € 1,000).